New Bush Telegraph Independent Stories since 1987

Housing Crisis Deepens Future Uncertain

October 13, 2022

By Amanda Findley

Barely a week goes by without numerous people contacting me simply looking for somewhere affordable to live. Almost every time my answer is the same - I'm so sorry, I wish I could help, have you tried...

The definition of affordable housing in practical terms is where you don't have to pay out more than 30 per cent of your income to keep a roof over your head. Anything over that affordable line means you are in housing stress of some sort. These days it's a rare thing indeed to meet someone who has anywhere near that 30 per cent.

The cruellest thing is something could have been done long before we reached this crisis point. Governments in Australia have chosen to let the so called 'free market' decide on the cost of rent.

Support for tax breaks for investment properties means that wealth is accumulating faster for those who could afford to buy into the property market and continues to squeeze people out. Successive governments have taken the popular way out and kept the tax breaks in place while reducing the spend on public housing.

The Liberals in NSW took this one step further and transferred a huge percentage of the public housing stock to not-for-profit housing groups. Here in the Shoalhaven those properties were mostly transferred to Southern Cross Housing.

Some of the homes transferred were not fit for people to live in and the measly budget that the Government supplied meant that fix ups are actually a waste of money - when what we need is new fit for purpose housing.

Monopoli board set up with money and houses. A nasty game. Support for tax breaks for investment properties means that wealth is accumulating faster for those who could afford to buy into the property market and continues to squeeze people out.
A nasty game that unfortunately is reality for many. Support for tax breaks for investment properties means that wealth is accumulating faster for those who could afford to buy into the property market and continues to squeeze people out. Photo credit: LightField Studios/

This is a band wagon I have been on for years. I can't tell you how many ministers I have handed a briefing document outlining how redeveloping some of Nowra's worst homes would be a win for the government, a win for the people and a win for business! All responses were happy lip service and no real action.

I recently brought a Mayoral Minute to the table to try and explore some ways that council could possibly raise revenue for a housing fund that could assist with building more homes. 

These are the recommendations that had majority support but not all councillors voted for it.

That Council:

1.    Receives a report from staff in a timely manner on potential proactive actions that can be taken to influence the availability of existing housing and increase the amount of affordable housing available in Shoalhaven, that specifically considers the following opportunities/potential Council actions:

a.    Special rate variation (SRV) to create an affordable housing fund.

Note: including how relevant Short Term Rental Accommodation (STRA) properties could be identified; options to create a specific rating category for STRA properties and the associated administrative process, including any legislative impediments, for the movement of relevant properties; the processes required to establish and administer the SRV; and the creation of a restricted reserve account where all funds raised through the SRV are to be used for the purpose of generating additional perpetual affordable housing in Shoalhaven.

b.    Land use planning options to better manage the amount of STRA available within Shoalhaven and its use/operation.

Note: including the potential for mapping and/or other provisions in Councils Local Environmental Plan and other planning documents to prohibit, cap/limit or allow the continuation of STRA in Shoalhaven.

c.    Run a campaign to reach non-resident ratepayers and STRA owners to urge them to consider renting their dwellings longer term to contribute to the local rental accommodation market and assist in the provision of additional much needed affordable housing opportunities.

Note: including all possible practical and cost-effective ways of reaching relevant owners, such as direct mail outs, and the potential associated costs.

2.    Considers the potential impact of any actions that are ultimately pursued in this regard on the visitor economy of the City (including research if necessary) and achieve a supportable balanced outcome, if possible, for the future.

Once the minute was made public, it drew some negative points of view as would be expected, but overwhelmingly people have been supportive and see it as a positive way to try and do something.

Targeting the residents who provide short term accommodation is to try and disincentivize a market that has turned a home into a business and partially contributed to the squeeze that is currently being felt.

I doubt this will yield any fruit, but we have to try, not unlike the frustrated Mayor of Dorset in Tasmania who did something similar.

There is no quick fix to the housing crisis. It needs all three levels of government rowing in the same direction and right now it feels like I am a professional hamster and the other levels of government have stuck the oars in the wheel. I still will keep trying.

Amanda Findley is the popularly elected Greens Mayor of Shoalhaven City Council and serving her second term as Mayor and her fourth term on Council.

Feature image: Graffiti on wall asking for Affordable Housing For Everyone Photo credit: M-SUR/

If you liked this article help us to plant trees in its honour. The New Bush Telegraph practices community journalism and plants a tree for every article published, although we hope to plant a whole lot more trees than just one. You can contribute as little as $5. 


This article is in the following category/ies:

  • Categories

  • Archives

    One comment on “Housing Crisis Deepens Future Uncertain

    1. While Amanda has identified one of the issues with affordable housing, it again is a half baked response from one of the 3 levels of government. STRA is more than just being Airbnb. We stopped renting our house for a couple of reasons. Lack of a good tenant (who pays on time, AND, looks after the property to a basic but acceptable level), and real estate agents who take 'their' money but provide no service are the 2 main reasons. People who rent from Airbnb, from my experience and anecdotally from others I have spoken to, are always more respectful of the house they rent. Amanda is also a little bit disingenuous on this issue if you look at Shoalhaven City Council. They always promote an increase in tourism like the panacea to everything. If you do that, there will never be enough accommodation so something has to give, and STRA is one of the peoples answer. Just look at Shoalhaven City Council caravan parks. They do their best to squeeze every $ from anyone who visits.
      Also if you look at overdevelopment that is happening in Amanda's patch, and is pretty much advocated by all levels of government, the situation will only get worse. If the answer to economic prosperity is always expansion, and developers don't care about anything more than a bucket of money, and all levels of government don't require them to give anything back, and we as a community don't care enough, nothing will change.
      On the other side of things, Amanda as mayor is overall doing a good job as at least she's putting something out there.
      So my final comment, is it needs a whole of government approach, federally down to local, and I wont even dare to suggest the full list of things to look at. Its well beyond my level of comprehension!!

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    Privacy PolicyTerms & Conditions
    Copyright © New Bush Telegraph Incorporated ABN: 42106732072
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram