New Bush Telegraph Independent Stories since 1987

The Manyana development is being assessed by the Federal Environment Minister. Here's how to have your say.

July 3, 2020

by Brendan Ryan & Bill Eger

A battle has been won but the war is far from over. The Heritage Trust offers us some legislation but there is no automatic protection. Now it’s up to us to make it work. 

There is something you can do right now that could have a big impact on whether or not the Manyana Beach Estate project goes ahead.

Ozy Homes have finally referred their project to the Federal Minister for the Environment. Now we need people who are concerned to tell the Minister why you believe it's essential to protect the only substantial piece of unburnt bushland left in Manyana after the Currowan mega-blaze this summer.

What can you do?
Send an email to (reference 2020/8704 Manyana Coast Pty Ltd) in your own words by July 7. State why you feel the Project could have a significant impact on federally listed threatened species. 

Anyone anywhere can make a comment. You don't have to be an expert, just someone who is passionate about protecting the health of our natural environment. Whether you're young or old, a highly-esteemed authority, nature-lover or local community member - your voice is valuable.

Here is a great link to get you started.

Of course, if you have first-hand accounts of threatened species in the area any time prior to the fires or have observed anything that suggests threatened species have used the site as refuge since the fires, this should be included. 

But even if you've never been to Manyana and just want to see this precious piece of mature native Australian bushland saved, penning a couple of lines voicing your opinion will make a difference. It will effectively be counted as a vote for protecting this land from bulldozers. And in a world where the voice of nature is often ignored, this is really important.

MMEA encourages you to express your views in your own way, but here are some points you may like to consider when making your submission:

1.    The land was already a biodiversity hotspot prior to the fires. Now it is essential refugia for any wildlife which escaped the flames. Its significance against such a compromised landscape has been amplified.

2.    This land is a source which the surrounding devastated Conjola National Park needs intact in order to regenerate. 

3.    There has not yet been a thorough investigation by the Government as to the repercussions of the extensive bushfires and the long-term effect the massive loss of wildlife and habitat will have on Federally listed threatened species.

4.    The "precautionary principle" should be used here. This simply means that a lack of scientific certainty (as is the case after the bushfires) should not be used as a reason to postpone measures to protect the environment. ie. we don't know yet what the fires have done to a whole lot of Federally listed species.

5.    The documentation submitted by Manyana Coast Pty Ltd (aka Ozy Homes) focuses only on a very limited number of threatened species (6 in total). Threatened ecological communities are not addressed and nor are the other 39 conservation dependant species listed in the EPBC Act, even though many have been recorded on site in the past. These include the Gang-gang Cockatoo, Glossy Black Cockatoo, Mainland Dusky Antechinus, Superb Lyrebird, Pilot Bird, Rufous Fantail and Yellow-Bellied Glider.

Mainland Dusky Antechinus (Antechinus mimetes) | The Mainlan… | Flickr
Mainland Dusky Antechius
Photo credit: Stephen Mahony

6.    Anyone who appreciates the vastness and severity of this summer's bushfires knows the Government needs to identify and protect any and all viable wildlife habitat in bushfire affected areas as a matter of urgency.

7.    If you have noticed unusual wildlife visitors to your area since the fires, talk about them. It is quite likely they have been displaced as a result of the fires. Equally, if you notice a species missing, mention that.

8.    There have been changes in the EPBC Act after the large-scale devastation of this summer's bushfires. But moving forward, we should be assessing damage done on a cumulative basis. This would take into account private habitat clearing, logging, habitat fragmentation and so on. The game has changed and so must the assessment process. Precedents must be set - before it's too late. Mature habitats destroyed now would take hundreds of years to replace.

9.    Any reference to out-dated environmental assessments (2006!) in the developer's referral is irrelevant.

10.    Recent, hurried surveys looking for specific species, were conducted under less than ideal conditions (Not the right time of year? Too soon after disturbance by fire. Immediately after the perimeter was fenced, etc) They cannot be relied on as evidence to support any claim the destruction of this habitat will not have a significant impact on threatened species.

If we can make the Minister sit up and take notice, our precious native wildlife will stand a chance of persisting for the long term in NSW. If we don’t, we’ll likely oversee extinction events. So please send your email today.

Brendan Ryan is the ecological consultant at Manyana Matters Environmental Association, and Bill Eger is the president.

The full referral documentation can be viewed here: (Reference 2020/8704 Manyana Coast Pty Ltd)

If you liked this article help us to plant trees in its honour. The New Bush Telegraph practices community journalism and plants a tree for every article published, although we hope to plant a whole lot more trees than just one. You can contribute as little as $5. 


This article is in the following category/ies:

  • Categories

  • Archives

    3 comments on “The Manyana development is being assessed by the Federal Environment Minister. Here's how to have your say.”

    1. The community of Manyana deserve full support for the reforestation of the Manyana bushland so the bush has its time to regenerate for essential homes for refugia. There are similar situations arising dotted throughout south eastern coastal lands within the Shoalhaven Region. The importance of retaining our national heritage by salvation of our natural environments is a national responsibility and the Manyana community have certainly shown their part in that with their support for the natural environment. You all deserve knighthoods. Please know you have much support from people all over Australia and I imagine from all over the world.

      Wheresoever you go, go with all your heart
      ~ Confucius~

    2. Saved as a favorite, I like your website! I
      could not refrain from commenting. Exceptionally well
      written! It’s the best time to make some plans for the
      longer term and it is time to be happy. I have
      read this publish and if I may I wish to suggest you some interesting things or advice.
      Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article.
      I want to learn more issues about it!

      Here is my web-site ... Jim

    3. I have no confidence in the Federal Environment Minister and mention must be made of the numerous orchids in that area. One was called the Opera House Greenhood but no mention of it has been made in recent years. Even one common orchid was overlooked some years ago during surveys for the rubbish tip which was proposed for the area.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    Privacy PolicyTerms & Conditions
    Copyright © New Bush Telegraph Incorporated ABN: 42106732072
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram