New Bush Telegraph Independent Stories since 1987
COMMUNITYSUSTAINABILITYENVIRONMENTPOLITICSCOUNCILARTSCLIMATE CHANGE

Conspiracy Theorists, Free Speech and Australian Politicians

January 16, 2021

By Stuart Rees

No need to be a wowser to insist that respect for truth cements civil society and that personal relationships, conduct in organisations and the implementation of governments’ policies depend on claims based on proven facts.  

Exchange of truths contributes to trust, but if trust is absent, shared values, and mutual obligations slip away. When that happens says Zuboff, (The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, 2019) confusion, uncertainty and distrust enable abusive power to fill the social void.

Conspiracy Theorists

A void in the US has been filled with falsehoods. From claims that Barack Obama was not born in America, to Trump’s assertion that the 2020 Presidential election was rigged, conspiracy theorists have contributed to division and conflict.  

Despite the absurdity of the theorists’ stories, millions swallow them. Trump claimed that an injection of bleach could be a cure for Covid. The QAnon theory said that Democrats, Hollywood and a global elite promoted a paedophile ring commanded by Hillary Clinton from a Washington Pizza shop that practised abduction, trafficking, torture, sexual abuse and cannibalisation of children.

Photo credit: Mika Baumeister - unsplash.com

Social media platforms facilitate opportunities to lie, and in that frenzied world, credibility depends on numbers of Twitter or Facebook followers, so why bother about evidence?  In the Trump nurtured deceits, self-promotion has become an alternative to careful compilation of facts.    

Australian Response  

Commentary on US politics should not allow holier than thou assumptions about the Australian political scene. Prime Minister Morrison and Deputy PM McCormack have not condemned Trump’s encouragement of lying and violence. Unwilling to be held accountable for rorts which look like fraud, they also protect their own conspiracy theorists.

Against the conclusions of over fifty US judges that there was no fraud in the Presidential election, George Christensen claims the Biden victory was stolen. On Facebook, Craig Kelly has supported Trump remedies for coronavirus, including the use of the anti-malaria drug hydroxychloroquine, even claiming there is a special place in hell for authorities who don’t authorise it.

On the violent invasion of the Capitol, Kelly argues that neo-Fascist and Marxists infiltrated Trump supporters, that leftist loyalists influenced the invasion of the Capitol and must be the real domestic terrorists.

In defence of these MPs, McCormack, the PM and Treasurer Frydenberg produce the lazy cliche that Australia is a free country, so Christensen and Kelly can say what they like. On the contrary, freedom of speech carries a responsibility to search for truth. It does not allow for lying, for crafting fantasy worlds let alone make statements easily interpreted as a license for violence.

Response to the Covid pandemic provides a lesson for those who think that freedom of speech is an absolute. Facing a potentially fatal virus, citizens’ freedoms have been secured by lockdowns to prevent infections and thereby protect freedoms. The argument that restrictions interfere with individual freedom may have motivated protesters to demand ‘don’t wear masks’, but this implied ‘spread the virus, it’s a form of freedom.’

Assessing Freedom of Speech

Two criteria, the test of reasonableness and concern for public interest, set boundaries on freedom of speech.

Reasonableness asks for evidence for speakers’ claims. Were judges wrong about the outcome of the US election? Is there any evidence that so-called Marxists were the instigators of the invasion of the Capitol?

Lying fails the test of reasonableness. Like lying in the classroom or in the workplace, it is corrosive and creates mistrust.

Public interest criteria presuppose a contribution to education about public wellbeing and respect for human rights. It is not in the public interest to make false claims about elections, to deny scientific evidence of global warming or collude in environmental destruction.  

Climate change protest London 2020. Photo credit: Ehimetalor Akhere Unuabona - unsplash

It is trite for Morrison to say that Australia is a free country, for Frydenberg to try to sound lofty by referring to Voltaire and for McCormack to say he’s against censorship.

McCormack’s utterances are also inaccurate and divisive. By comparing the right-wing thugs who invaded the US Capitol with protesters in the Black Lives Matter movement, he glosses over the massive racial divides which contribute to injustice in Australia and the US.

McCormack values individual rights and seems to advocate the privatisation of speech. Instead, Australia desperately needs a political movement to advocate a language for humanity, for social equality and for humane governance.    

The brilliant Turkish novelist and political commentator, Ece Temelkuran, (How to Lose a Country 2019), says if citizens do not spot trends that erode truths, human rights and political accountability, a country’s democratic traditions can be easily lost. She was speaking about Turkey, but her observations apply to every democracy.

Once anti-truth, anti-democratic forces gain momentum, a post-modern world arrives where everyone has their own version of truth; and the universals that have cemented societies – as in reliance on science, on respect for the rule of law and on ethics of responsibility – are discarded.

Freedom of speech is invaluable but not via freedom which ignores falsehoods, not the Trump, conspiratorial variety.  

Stuart Rees

Stuart Rees OAM is Professor Emeritus, University of Sydney, recipient of the Jerusalem (Akl Quds) Peace Prize and author of the new book “Cruelty or Humanity”. A human rights activist, poet, novelist, and Founder Director of the Sydney Peace Foundation.

Feature Image: Flat Earth Concept By Foto Helin/Shutterstock

If you liked this article help us to plant trees in its honour. The New Bush Telegraph practices community journalism and plants a tree for every article published, although we hope to plant a whole lot more trees than just one. You can contribute as little as $5. 

FIND OUT MORE / DONATE

This article is in the following category/ies:

  • Categories

  • Archives

    One comment on “Conspiracy Theorists, Free Speech and Australian Politicians”

    1. ...yes, a post-modern world where - as Asimov laments - "my ignorance is as good as your knowledge"

      sad thing is....the vast majority of people are so consumed with the pursuit of comfort that there is no will and little capacity to spot trends (unless they are in fashion or food or furnishings...)

      thanks, Stuart.
      another enjoyable read

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Join us

    For only $20 (per annum, $10 concession) you can become a member of The New Bush Telegraph Incorporated. Membership to an incorporated association shows your support and gives you voting rights at annual general meetings, access to volunteer opportunities and special member events.

    FIND OUT MORE
    Subscribe to our newsletter
    Keep up to date with all the news from The New Bush Telegraph and be notified of new articles when they are published. It’s the best way to stay in touch and never miss out on those important local issues. You can unsubscribe at any time.
    * indicates required

    Donate to the New Bush Telegraph

    The New Bush Telegraph is a not-for-profit community initiative.

    Support us to grow and reach our goals by considering making a donation.

    COMMUNITYSUSTAINABILITY
    ENVIRONMENTPOLITICS
    COUNCIL
    ARTSCLIMATE CHANGE
    ABOUTLETTERS TO THE EDITORCONTACT

    Archives

    #125 Spring 2019#120 Winter 2018#109 Spring 2015#108 Winter 2015#107 Autumn 2015#106 Winter 2010#105 Late Spring 2009#104 Winter 2009#103 Autumn 2009#102 Summer 2008#101 Winter / Spring 2008#100 Late Autumn 2008#99 Late Summer  2008#98 Summer 2007#97 Spring 2007#96 Winter 2007#95 Autumn 2007
    New Bush Telegraph - Independent Publishing Since 1987
    Privacy PolicyTerms & Conditions
    Copyright © New Bush Telegraph Incorporated ABN: 42106732072
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram